Showing posts with label racism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label racism. Show all posts

Saturday, August 3, 2013

Devil in the Grove





Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America

by Gilbert King

Once upon a time, on a mild February evening in central Florida, a young woman and her estranged husband, in an attempt to reconcile, went for a drive while sharing a bottle of whiskey.  At some point the man turned the car into what appeared to be a dirt road, but the wheels lost traction and the car became hopelessly stuck.  Two men, recently discharged from the army after having served their country in World War II, were driving by and stopped to see if they could help.  The estranged husband offered the whiskey bottle to the good Samaritans and then ordered them to get to work and extricate the car.  The veterans did not appreciate being treated like slaves by the man they stopped to help, and a fight broke out leaving the husband out cold in the dirt.  The men gave the woman a ride in their car and dropped her off a few miles away.  In the wee hours of the next morning, another man picked the wife up and dropped her off in front of a roadside diner at a crossroads in Okahumpka, Florida.  The year was 1948.  The two war veterans were black; everyone else involved was white.

A short time later, the woman’s husband and another man stopped at the diner and the reunited couple then claimed that a group of four black men had raped her, despite having told the security man at the diner, that after beating up her husband, the men had not hurt her.  She was just a bit tired, she had said, from having walked a fair distance.  Why Norma and Willie Pagett concocted this story is part of the mystery of the Groveland Four, a criminal case that riveted the nation during the early days of the American Civil Rights movement.  Within hours of the incident, the two erstwhile good Samaritans and a third young man were arrested, tortured, and jailed for the alleged rape.  A fourth man, Ernest Thomas, was fleeing Lake County to avoid being murdered by gangsters when he was shot and killed by Willis McCall, the all-powerful Lake County sheriff.  Thomas became the forth man.

At that time in our nation’s history the lynching of black men was a common practice in central Florida.  The empty country with vast orange groves remained a stronghold for the Ku Klux Klan, a white supremacist group which formed in reaction to the Reformation following the Civil War.  The Klan, made up of white men who feared racial integration, Communism, and illegal immigrants, considered itself a Christian fraternal organization not unlike the Elks, but with a more menacing agenda.  In reality the Klan was a terrorist organization which co-opted local law enforcement and governments.   Sheriff McCall, a closeted Klan member, found himself in the difficult position of having to protect the three young black men in his custody from a violent and outraged lynch mob.  However, the pleasure of beating confessions out of two of the men, with a little help from some of his good ol’ boys in law enforcement, more than made up for this hardship.  Only one suspect, Walter Irvin, refused to give in to the coercion.  He never confessed, even when offered a plea bargain: life in prison as opposed to the electric chair.

As word spread throughout the black community in America that an outrage had been committed against four innocent men, Florida’s white establishment – from the local police up to the governor – made a mockery of the rule of law in its zeal to protect the “flower of southern womanhood”.  A team of lawyers from the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) headed up by one of the nation’s greatest legal minds traveled from New York City to Lake County in order to defend the three young men in court.  Thurgood Marshall already had a string of civil rights victories under his belt, having successfully argued Chambers vs Florida before the United States Supreme Court which overturned the murder convictions of four wrongly accused black men whose confessions had been coerced by police in Broward County.  

Marshall was a long-term thinker when it came to matters of law and therefore he chose his cases carefully.  His goal was to overturn Plessy vs Ferguson (1896), a Supreme Court ruling that upheld the doctrine of “separate but equal” public facilities as the basis for legalizing racial segregation.  In order to do that, Marshall strategically crafted his arguments in every case so that each judge’s ruling in some way advanced his cause or gave him an opportunity to chip away at the segregationist doctrine.  By the time President Lyndon Johnson appointed Thurgood Marshall to the Supreme Court, segregation had ended, in large part due to his efforts.

Devil in the Grove is a gripping history of not only the Groveland Four case but of Thurgood Marshall’s life and career.  There are passages which describe a Gestapo-like climate in Florida at a time when the United States was engaged in the “Cold War” against the spread of Communism.  The hypocrisy of the brutal treatment of black Americans by their white neighbors, so similar to the Nazi’s persecution of Jews, pleased Russian and Chinese Communist leaders tremendously, and the increasingly ugly situation became a national embarrassment.  President Harry S. Truman, directed the Federal Bureau of Investigation to review the facts of the case.  J. Edgar Hoover and Thurgood Marshall, despite their mutual antipathy, used each other to support their respective agendas:  ferreting out Communists and bringing justice to the Groveland Four.

What happened in Lake County, Florida, in 1948 and the eventual outcome of the trail andsubsequent appeals, is important to understand in light of the recent criminal trial in neighboring Seminole County, in which a self-appointed security guard followed and then shot to death an unarmed teenage boy whose only crime was “looking suspicious”.  Florida Statute 776.013 Home protection; use of deadly force; presumption of fear of death or great bodily harm, the so called “Stand Your Ground” law, states that “A person who is not engaged in an unlawful activity and who is attacked in any other place where he or she has a right to be has no duty to retreat and has the right to stand his or her ground and meet force with force, including deadly force if he or she reasonably believes it is necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony.”

Trayvon Martin was not engaged in an unlawful activity;he was followed, perhaps threatened by a man with a gun who didn’t like the way he looked;  he had a right to be walking to his father’s house and had no duty to retreat;  he stood his ground and fought the armed man who wouldn’t leave him alone; at some point, he overpowered his aggressor with physical strength and athleticism;  his assailant, in the midst of this brawl, managed to pull the trigger of his handgun.  Ten minutes later, Trayvon Martin died, and seventeen months after that, George Zimmerman walked out of the courthouse a free man.

While the Trayvon Martin and Groveland Four cases have little similarity, there are some haunting echoes from central Florida’s past which George Zimmerman’s murder trial amplified.   The entire community in the Groveland case tacitly conspired to deny four black men their right to live.  Both the Groveland and Martin cases attracted Federal attention to prevent a lynching in the first instance, and to arrest the shooter in the second.  The degree to which racism on the part of George Zimmerman led to Trayvon Martin’s death is a question which is impossible to answer.  Given Zimmerman’s history of calling 911, however, it is clear that he believed a black teenage boy wearing a hoodie had no legitimate business walking on a sidewalk in the community he was patrolling.  The bigger question this case presents is why the local police were so reluctant to arrest George Zimmerman for Trayvon Martin’s death.  Had they done so, it is likely that no one outside of Florida would ever have heard of Trayvon Martin.

In 1948, brutal treatment of black suspects was done behind closed doors and McCall congratulated himself for delivering three breathing bodies and two confessions to the state prison.  Under the veneer of upholding the laws of the land, the Florida State judicial system suffered from the same institutional racism as the Lake County police department.  The judge at the murder trial suppressed evidence which would have exonerated the Groveland boys, and used every trick he could conjure up to prevent that “uppity negro” lawyer from the NAACP from representing them.

In 2012, George Zimmerman claimed he shot Trayvon Martin in self defense and used the “Stand Your Ground” statute to justify his actions.  It is unlikely that he intended to kill anyone that evening; he probably believed that the gun would scare the “suspicious looking” boy out of the neighborhood.  Only Zimmerman knows what he did and said that provoked the physical altercation which resulted in Martin’s death: as the saying goes, two people can keep a secret if one of them is dead.  In the aftermath of his acquittal, many Americans believe the Federal government should prosecute Zimmerman for committing a hate crime and/or for denying Martin his civil rights. Both cases would be difficult to win unless Florida’s prosecution team did an inept job (which is possible given how unenthusiastic the state was about arresting Zimmerman in the first place) and overlooked or ignored evidence of racism on the part of Zimmerman.  At a minimum, the Justice Department should review every aspect of the case to be sure that the state of Florida did its job.

In the years between the Groveland and Zimmerman cases, life for black Americans has changed profoundly for the better, thanks in large part to the work of Thurgood Marshall and the NAACP.  Marshall’s unassailable arguments against segregation and abuses by police and criminal prosecutors continue to strengthen the Constitution for everyone’s benefit.  Racist feelings, unfortunately, persist to varying degrees depending on one’s family and community values.  

It was President Franklin Delano Roosevelt who famously said “we have nothing to fear but fear itself” and fear is what led George Zimmerman to carry a loaded handgun.  Fear is what made Trayvon Martin fight for his life.  Fear is what caused Zimmerman to pull the trigger.  Fear is driving the parents of black boys to protest the outcome of the trial.  Finally, fear is the reason why so many Americans feel the need to own guns.  Rather than talk to each other to resolve differences we buy guns and threaten to kill anyone who makes us feel afraid.  If George Zimmerman had had an ounce of courage, he would have left Trayvon Martin alone.  Conversely, if  the unarmed Trayvon Martin hadn’t stood his ground, he might still be alive.

Copyright 2013 Teresa Friedlander, all rights reserved
 

Wednesday, June 22, 2011

Adventures of Huckleberry Finn

by Mark Twain

Mark Twain enjoyed ruffling feathers by poking fun at politicians and preachers, but he could not possibly have foreseen, when he published Adventures of Huckleberry Finn in 1884, that this novel would be stirring controversy well into the 21st century. When it first appeared in the United States, Twain’s use of common speech between characters was so unprecedented that many librarians considered the book “trash” and refused to carry it. The subject matter, too, caused some uneasiness although it would be another century before Americans would have the vocabulary to discuss race relations intelligently. In my lifetime, black Americans have gone from segregation to the White House. Just the same, most white Americans are still uneasy discussing race in mixed settings. We are afraid of giving offence, of sounding insensitive, of betraying hidden racist tendencies. One word in particular – “nigger” – makes most of us cringe to the extent that we won’t say it even to ourselves. What is it about that word that makes us so uncomfortable?

In Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, the so-called “n-word” appears 219 times. “Nigger” is a bastardized form of the word “negro”, meaning black, which came into common usage in colonial times. When Mark Twain, wrote this book using “negro” would have seemed odd in dialog that was meant to capture the way people spoke. Recently, a publishing house catering to schools issued a sanitized version of the book, replacing “nigger” with “slave” and “injun” with “indian”. Rather than calming the controversy, these well-intentioned revisions have inadvertently started an important conversation in America about how slavery still defines us.

Before Huckleberry Finn there was Tom Sawyer: The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is a delightful story of childhood along the banks of the Mississippi River. Tom is an engaging, opportunistic, and fearless boy who can’t avoid trouble. One of his friends is Huckleberry Finn, the motherless son of a shiftless and abusive drunkard. The two boys witness a murder but allow an innocent man to be jailed for the crime out of fear for their own safety. This is the first moral dilemma that Huck has to face in his life. In the end, the truth comes out and the innocent man is freed; and Tom and Huck find hidden treasure and become wealthy.

Huckleberry Finn is a much more nuanced and interesting character than Tom Sawyer. Adventures of Huckleberry Finn takes place after Tom and Huck come out of hiding and reveal their wealth. Huck is adopted by the “Widder” Douglas and her sister Miss Watson, who owns a slave named Jim. Huck chafes under the civilizing influence of the sisters and runs off to hide out with Tom and his gang. Huck’s father, “Pap”, hearing of Huck’s fortune, reappears to assert his parental rights. He tracks Huck down and confines him in a remote cabin in conditions resembling slavery. Huck contrives to fake his death and flees to seek his fortune on the mighty Mississippi River.

Meanwhile Jim, hearing that Miss Watson plans to “sell him down the river”, runs away and by chance he and Huck meet up on an uninhabited island. Their reunion is comical in that Jim, believing Huck to be dead, thinks he is encountering a ghost. It takes Huck a while to overcome Jim’s superstitions but eventually the two team up to escape their respective horrors. Huck, being a Christian, has been taught the difference between right and wrong and so he is conflicted about whether or not to turn Jim in, after all Jim is Miss Watson’s property. While Huck believes he is guilty of a crime for helping Jim escape from kind Miss Watson, it is a dilemma he chooses to live with until he reaches an epiphany: that Jim is not only his true friend, but a human being in his own right.

The friendship between Huck and Jim is one of the sweetest in American literature because Huck’s uneducated mind follows his heart to a place of deep appreciation and compassion. On the surface, Jim is the stereotypical slave: ignorant, superstitious, passive, cajoling, humble, and servile. What we learn is that despite his lack of education and his pandering behavior, he possesses a great wisdom and morality which enable him to teach Huck by example and willingly put himself at risk to protect his young friend.

Mark Twain was an astute observer of the human species and used his works of fiction and journalism to point out hypocrisies and self-delusions. During their travels, Huck and Jim encounter a couple of grifters who latch onto them for their own advantage. The grifters who come to be called “The King” and “The Duke” move from town to town selling tickets to a bogus show which they call “The Royal Nonesuch”. Huck and Jim cannot escape from these menacing con artists and end up being pawns in a scheme to steal the inheritance from an orphaned girl who befriends Huck. He manages to thwart the thieves and rejoin Jim on the raft, but The King and The Duke catch up with them and cook up a scheme to sell news of Jim’s whereabouts in order to collect a reward. Huckleberry Finn could have ended in tragedy, but Mark Twain had a light heart; he tied up all the loose ends and made Jim a free man.

Samuel Clemons, who wrote under several pseudonyms, was born in 1835, in Florida, Missouri, not far from the Mississippi River. As a youth, he worked as a printer’s apprentice and typesetter. Drawn to the mighty river, he earned his riverboat pilot’s license, which required that he understand the ever-changing dynamics of moving water in order to guide boats into port. His career ended when the Civil War halted river traffic. Mr. Clemons then followed his brother, Orion, to the Nevada Territory and tried his luck at mining. The people he met during his travels provided fodder for his writing career which took off following the publication of “The Celebrated Frog of Calaveras County”, a humorous piece about a man with a betting problem. The pen name “Mark Twain” comes from a nautical term referring to the depth of water needed for a riverboat to clear, an apt metaphor for an author who sought to elucidate hypocrisies, delusions, and frauds.

Mark Twain’s success as a writer led to his marriage to Olivia Langdon, a wealthy woman from a liberal, Connecticut family. Through this connection, he met Harriet Beecher Stowe, Frederick Douglass, and other Abolitionists who helped shape his views about slavery, which - like Huck’s, and like America’s – evolved. Mark Twain was born in a time when people legally kept slaves. As an adult, he saw that slavery was an evil practice and famously said that Emancipation freed the entire nation from the chains of slavery.

Ending slavery in America – a moral imperative – did not usher in a golden age of harmony between the races. Hundreds of thousands of newly freed slaves who owned nothing and belonged nowhere suddenly had responsibility for themselves. Some remained where they were, working the same land as before, beholden to a boss instead of owned by a master. Others moved to cities in search of work. A fortunate few had valuable skills and property which enabled them to create businesses and farms of their own. What they all shared was the taint of slavery, of somehow being less than human and therefore subject to scorn and revulsion. The word “nigger” carries this ugliness and hatred with it to this day.

While removing the offensive epithet from Huckleberry Finn might make certain students, parents, and teachers more comfortable, it does a great disservice to the book and to the people on whose backs the plantation economy was built. Sanitizing Mark Twain’s American literary classic takes away an opportunity for students in mixed race settings to have the discussion about why a little six-letter word can have such power, and how we might one day strip that power away.

Copyright 2011, Teresa Friedlander, all rights reserved

Thursday, October 14, 2010

Cry the Beloved Country

Cry the Beloved Country by Alan Paton

Book review by Teresa Friedlander, copyright 2010, all rights reserved


If the 2010 World Cup Soccer Tournament was South Africa’s “coming out” party, then the nation did herself proud; hosting 32 teams and as many as three million spectators in 10 venues. From June 11 through July 11, 2010, the world watched as elimination matches whittled the field down to Spain and the Netherlands, ultimately giving Spain its first World Cup title. Throughout it all, we heard the buzzing of vuvuzelas, the plastic horns blown by South African spectators in a new “fanfare for the common man”. How far South Africa has come since the days of Apartheid – constitutional racial segregation – and, before that, the so called “Pass Laws” which required Blacks to carry documents at all times. To see the smiling faces and to hear the joyful noises of the Black South African fans one could never guess that as recently as 1990, these good people were denied the rights and benefits of full citizenship.

The story of South Africa has many parallels to that of the United States of America: European nations colonized parts of it, marginalized the native population, and exploited the abundant natural resources. Civil unrest between various factions led to a unified government and the ruin of the native people, who lost their cultural and tribal identities. Where the stories diverge is in terms of civil rights. The southern United States’ economies were built on slave labor and after that was abolished in 1865, these states enacted so called “Jim Crow” laws to legalize segregation of the races. At no time in our history, however, has slavery or segregation been the law of the land. Indeed, the questions of slavery and whether Africans might be entitled to full citizenship vexed the attendees of the first Constitutional Convention of the United States of America. It took another century after slavery was abolished to invalidate state laws favoring segregation, and the better part of fifty years hence to make racial discrimination completely unacceptable.

South Africa’s story is also different from ours in terms of the dominant culture. The Netherlands was the first European nation to colonize southern Africa in the 1600s and descendents of these settlers , or the Boers, make up a significant part of the current population. Great Britain also established colonies in southern Africa by the beginning of the 1800s. The discovery of diamonds and gold fueled competition for dominance of southern Africa and a series of civil wars ensued. Great Britain won the second Boer War in 1902, after losing the first Boer War in 1881, and thus gained control. In 1909, the British Parliament created the Union of South Africa, giving it the same status as Australia and Canada, a dominion under the monarchy. The new government passed the South Africa Act which created a strong central government and facilitated laws severely limiting the civil rights of Black South Africans. The ruling majority was mostly English-speaking, but Afrikaans was widely spoken by both Black and white South Africans. Therefore, in addition to racial segregation, South Africa was divided by language.

Cry the Beloved Country by Alan Paton, tells the story of Black South Africans during this sorry chapter in that nation’s history. It is a tragic and beautiful novel about a Black minister who has watched the social fabric of his tribe disintegrate while the young adults migrated to shanty towns on the outskirts of the big cities to look for work. The Pass Laws Act of 1952 required that all Blacks over the age of 16 carry a pass book at all times, to prove their identity, residency, employment status, and permission to travel. Failure to produce the pass book on demand was grounds for immediate imprisonment. Alan Paton, a white South African, worked in the prison system and became intimately familiar with the degrading impact of the pass laws. He learned of the lost generation of Blacks who abandoned their tribes and families in search of employment in Johannesburg, Pietermaritzburg, Bloemfontein, and other large cities. He understood the devastating effect of these migrations on the women, children and old people who were left behind. As the main character, the Reverend Stephen Kumalo, laments “when people go to Johannesburg, they never come back. They do not even write anymore.”

In the story, the Reverend’s sister and son had both disappeared into Johannesburg and would have remained missing had he not received a letter from a fellow priest informing him of his sister’s ill health. This news caused the Reverend and his wife to acknowledge that their son, Absalom, would never need the money they had saved for his education in the tribal school, and so they decided to use that money to send the Reverend to Johannesburg to give aid and comfort to his sister. At the train station, a neighbor asked the Reverend Kumalo to ask after his daughter – another missing person – who was in the employ of the daughter-in-law of the local white landowner. In the end, the Reverend, the white landowner, the Reverend’s son, the missing girl, the white landowner’s daughter-in-law and grandson discover their lives are intertwined by a tragedy resulting from the tribal breakdown that sent Absalom and his peers to Johannesburg. Out of this tragedy, a beautiful friendship grows which promises to heal the land laid waste by overgrazing cattle and inappropriate land cultivation.

Cry the Beloved Country reads like an epic poem, with almost musical phrasing. The opening line of the book, “There is a lovely road that runs from Ixopo into the hills. These hills are grass-covered and rolling, and they are lovely beyond any singing of it.” is repeated several times like the refrain of a sad song. Mr. Paton understood the profoundly degrading effect that segregation had on both the people and the land as well as the deep sense of longing for things to be different on the part of so many. Those lush green hills of the opening line were off limits to the Black South Africans’ starving cattle, the traditional measure of a man’s wealth.

Mr. Paton’s dialog captures the essence of the Zulu language and its almost exclusive use of the present tense. This has the effect of bringing out the forgiving and compassionate nature of the Reverend Kumalo and the gentleness of the rural Zulu people. Once corrupted by the big city, however, the Blacks quickly become bitter and angry and lose all sense of morals. Life in the shanty towns is brutally ugly and crime is rampant, and the language reflects this.

In the decades since Cry the Beloved Country was published, South Africa has changed profoundly: the Pass Laws were replaced by Apartheid, officially consolidating political power and wealth in the ruling white minority population; Apartheid fell to global pressure; Nelson Mandela – a Black South African who had spent years in prison – was elected president; and the Fédération Internationale de Football Association, FIFA, voted to hold the 2010 World Cup in the Republic of South Africa. Life is still far from perfect in this nation of 50 million people, 80 per cent of whom are Black, but things are getting better. The 2010 World Cup was a celebration of progress, if not perfection.

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

The Dew Breaker


The Dew Breaker by Edwige Danticat

Book review by Teresa Friedlander, Copyright 2010

There are epic novels which educate the reader by integrating pages from history with captivating stories of people living through world-changing events; and then there are those by modern authors, which only hint at the larger historical context surrounding their characters. The Dew Breaker falls into the latter category, and does this by using discrete stories to describe how the actions of the powerful few can ruin the lives of the powerless many for generations, even centuries. To understand this book, to appreciate it fully, the reader owes it to him- or herself to learn the back story:

Once upon a time, on a small tropical island in the Caribbean Sea, a peaceful population of Arawak-speaking Taínos (Native Americans) lived in harmony with nature. The Taínos grew cotton, and from this crafted fishing nets; they harvested cassava roots and maize as well. The Taínos’ only enemies were the cannibalistic Caribs who invaded from time to time, requiring them to develop defensive weapons and strategies. Life on this island, which the Taínos called “Ayiti”, was idyllic and the people enjoyed feasting, worshipping, and procreating. One day, however, enormous boats filled with strange-looking men with light skin and heavy clothing arrived; and the world, as the Taínos knew it, ended.

The year was 1492 and the captain of the boats was the Spanish explorer, Christopher Columbus. The beautiful and fertile island on which Columbus found himself is a place that has endured almost endless hardship and suffering in the 500 plus years since. Spain controlled the island, then called Hispañola, for almost a century before leaving it vulnerable to pirates originally from England, The Netherlands, and France. The Taíno people, meanwhile, all but disappeared. By 1664, France had formally claimed the western half of the island as a permanent settlement and the French West Indies Company established vast tobacco, indigo, cotton, cacao, coffee, and sugar cane plantations. The plantations required a constant supply of slaves from Africa, in order to realize their full economic potential, because slaves were literally worked to death. In the 18th century, Saint-Domingue – the French part of Hispañola – came to be called the “Pearl of the Antilles” given its richness and productivity. As much as 60 per cent of the coffee and 40 per cent of the sugar consumed by Europeans came from this tiny colony, no bigger than the state of Maryland.

At its height, Saint-Domingue’s slave population numbered 500,000 while its ruling white population was a mere 32,000, or 16 per cent of the total. In order to maintain control, slave owners resorted to extreme brutality and coercion, and there was no limit to the degradation or cruelty imposed on slaves in service to the colony’s economic imperative. The French Revolution created fissures in the established social and political order; and in 1790 a civil war broke out when free men of color demanded full French citizenship as spelled out in the “Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen”, a document similar to the United States’ Declaration of Independence. A delegation of free black men travelled to France and received a grant of full citizenship from the Legislative Assembly there. The rulers of the colony, however, did not agree and refused to recognize free men of color as full citizens. The dispute was further complicated by racial stratification: mulattos were considered of higher status than Africans, and under French law freed slaves could themselves own slaves.

In 1793, an intelligent and charismatic free man, Francois-Dominique Toussaint-L’ouverture, led a slave rebellion which eventually succeeded in driving out the French forces and repelling the opportunistic British invaders, while vanquishing the colonial slave holders. Toussaint-L’ouverture then wrote a constitution for a new government and declared himself governor for life. He was not a despot; rather he was a visionary leader, similar to our own Founding Fathers. During his brief tenure, Toussaint-L’ouverture re-established trade with Britain and the United States of America. Meanwhile, Napoleon Bonaparte wanted the colony back under France’s dominion and resorted to treachery to achieve this end. In 1802, Toussaint-L’ouverture signed a treaty with France to return the colony to French rule on the condition that slavery would not return. Three weeks later, Toussaint-L’ouverture and his family were deported to France where he died in jail a short time later. Napoleon’s forces fought a brutal war of aggression against the freed slaves in order to reinstate slavery in the colony, however the brief taste of freedom which Toussaint-L’ouverture had achieved for the population unified them and by 1804, the French withdrew. General Jean-Jacques Dessalines declared independence and named the new nation, Haiti, which meant “land of mountains” in the Taínos’ language.

In order to survive economically, Haiti was obliged to repay France the price of so-called lost property (land, equipment, and slaves) in the amount of 150 million gold francs. France, supported by Britain and the United States, imposed a trade embargo against Haiti forcing the new and fragile nation to pay this debt which they finally did in 1947.

Haiti enjoyed a brief period of peace and relative prosperity from 1874 until 1911. During this time artists, writers, and musicians flourished and the nation developed a unique cultural identity, influenced by Voodoo, Christianity, and African traditions. A small community of German émigrés meanwhile established itself and slowly gained control of 80 per cent of Haiti’s international trade as well as its public utilities and port access. This did not sit well with the United States, given the hostile behavior of the Germans in Europe, and so a group of American investors bought control of the National Bank of Haiti, where the nation’s treasure was on deposit. In order to protect the financial interests of these American investors, President Woodrow Wilson agreed to send occupying forces. During this time, the United States exploited its role as Haiti’s legal protector and revived an old law requiring peasants to perform hard labor in lieu of paying road taxes. Between 1915 and 1918, these de facto slaves built 470 miles of paved road, among other projects. In 1919, the Haitians revolted and as many as 15,000 civilians died. To reestablish order, the United States installed a dictator. Then the Great Depression ruined Haiti’s already frail economy and the United States slowly withdrew its forces. From 1934 through 1957, Haiti suffered a prolonged period of political instability until a former Minister of Health and widely respected humanitarian, Dr. Francois Duvalier, was democratically elected president.

It didn’t take long before President Duvalier, “Papa Doc” as he liked to be called, established a dictatorship and intimidated the Haitian people through kidnappings, beatings, and murders by a “volunteer” army called the Tonton Macoutes (after a Voodoo monster). To those living in fear, the Macoutes were called “Dew Breakers” because they usually came in the early morning hours, leaving footprints in the heavy dew. Papa Doc aimed to rid Haiti of its mulatto elite population and this resulted in a mass exodus of the country’s best educated and most skilled people. At the same time, Papa Doc won the favor of many in the black middle class by providing services and utilities – such as water, sewers, and paved roads – to previously neglected neighborhoods. It was from this population that he recruited his “volunteer” Macoutes.

Papa Doc died in 1971 and his 19 year old son, Jean-Claude Duvalier, took power. “Baby Doc” was predictably inept and very corrupt. He pocketed vast sums of public money and foreign aid, and married a glamorous mulatto divorcee in a lavish ceremony. This did not sit well with anyone, including his own mother, so he allowed his wife to send his mother to live in exile. When Pope Jean Paul II visited Haiti in 1983, he was horrified by what he saw and condemned Baby Doc’s regime. Three years later, Baby Doc and his wife fled the country.

The dew breaker referred to in the title, turns out to be a loving father and devoted husband who, after moving to New York, tries to forget his past. The ghosts of his victims, however, follow him and refuse to grant him peace. Award-winning author, Edwige Danticat, evokes the world of denial and acceptance that many Haitian refugees found themselves living in following the brutal Duvalier years. She does this through a collection of interconnected stories, each of which could stand on its own, but together tell the tragic story of a little nation which seems eternally cursed.

Democracy and freedom have a hard time taking root in Haiti: for every good and legally elected president, there seem to be two or three despots poised to take control. In 2006, Rene Preval was elected and showed promise as a legitimate leader. And then the earthquake happened. Is Haiti the realization of Dante’s Inferno here on earth, or is this tiny nation a living, breathing example of the triumph of the human spirit? If we recognize that Columbus’ conquest of Ayiti set in motion 500 years of suffering, the answer, I think, is both, because the Haitian people have a reputation as some of the happiest, most generous people on earth. The bigger question posed by this book, is whether we all recognize that brutality and despotism are totally colorblind, kept at bay only by the rule of law.

Friday, January 30, 2009

On Slavery






REQUIRED READING: On Slavery
By Teresa Friedlander (copyright 2008)

Uncle Tom’s Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe
The Lost German Slave Girl by John Bailey
The Known World by Edward P. Jones

Why do humans enslave their brethren? One answer is that slave labor enables the powerful to achieve great things. Another answer is that slaves, being denied their free will, serve at the pleasure of their masters. A third answer is that slavery is the most severe form of racism because one race can justify enslaving another by claiming genetic superiority. There are many answers to this question, and coupled with the pervasiveness of racism and tribal hatred, suggest that as a species, we still have work to do.

Harriet Beecher Stowe (1811-1896) was the sensitive and insightful daughter of a minister who preached vehemently about the evils of slavery during the time when the United States of America was embroiled in an angry debate over whether new slave states should be admitted to the Union. Harriet Beecher had the benefit of a good education and a successful marriage to Calvin Stowe, a professor at a theological seminary in Cincinnati, Ohio. While raising their seven children, Mrs. Stowe became a well-known writer and published 30 books, the most famous of which is Uncle Tom’s Cabin. This book, a classic piece of American literature, was an immediate best-seller and served to raise the consciousness of many Americans, particularly in the north, about the horrors of slavery. President Abraham Lincoln is said to have credited Harriet Beecher Stowe with starting the Civil War because of the public outcry her book generated.

Uncle Tom, a middle-aged husband and father, starts out as the property of Kentucky farmers, Arthur and Emily Shelby. Mr. and Mrs. Shelby express genuine affection for their slaves, however, when bad times come they decide to reduce their inventory. In addition to Tom, the Shelbys plan to sell Harry, the son of Mrs. Shelby’s maid, Eliza. Eliza will not be parted from her son, so she and Harry escape in the hope of reaching Canada where Eliza’s husband lives in freedom. Their journey is fraught with hardship and peril given the cold winter and the pursuit of a ruthless slave catcher.

Meanwhile Tom, accepting his fate with quiet dignity, is taken away from his family and home by a slave trader. While traveling down the river to the slave market, a golden-haired and blue-eyed child named Eva falls overboard. Tom dives in and saves her from drowning. Eva’s father, Augustine St. Clare, purchases Tom out of gratitude for his heroism and brings him home to New Orleans. Tom and Eva become very attached to one another, but the little girl falls ill and eventually dies. Harriet Beecher Stowe uses the St. Clare household as a forum for discussing attitudes toward slavery. Mr. St. Clare does not like the institution of slavery, but knows no other way to make a profit off his land. Eva’s Aunt Ophelia, on the other hand, is an abolitionist but feels disgust toward blacks. In the end, however, Eva through her charitable heart teaches her aunt to love the slaves as humans. Shattered by Eva’s death, Mr. St. Clare decides to give Tom his freedom, but is murdered before he is able to do this. Mrs. St. Clare shares none of her late husband’s humanity and sells Tom to a vicious plantation owner named Simon Legree.

Simon Legree’s plantation is a hellish place where young black women are kept for sex and slaves are ordered to beat one another. Tom, being the gentle, loving, and spiritual person he is, cannot obey his master’s order to beat a fellow slave. Mr. Legree decides to beat the Christianity out of Tom but fails. Just the same, Tom suffers a crisis of faith wondering how a loving God can let such cruelty stand. Eva appears to him in a vision and restores his faith in Christianity. Thus restored, Tom facilitates the escape of two women from Mr. Legree’s sex slavery and is able to withstand the beatings aimed at making him reveal the whereabouts of the runaways. As death approaches, Tom forgives Mr. Legree and men who are beating him. The end of the story features a tragic and ironic twist which brought thousands of readers to tears.

Uncle Tom’s Cabin unfortunately fell into disfavor during the civil rights era of the 1960s. Many African Americans at the time felt it described African slaves as so downtrodden that they meekly accepted beatings and degradation by cruel masters. “Uncle Tom” became a pejorative label for a black man who didn’t join the fight against segregation. This is a sad mischaracterization because Uncle Tom’s Cabin was one of the most important works of the Abolitionist cause, and ultimately set the stage for the end of segregation.

Slavery has been a human practice since before recorded history. The ancient Babylonians under their Code of the Hammurabi (circa 1800 BC) legitimized slavery as a redress for serious crimes against others. In the 1700s, slave labor in North America enabled the British Colonies to develop vast cotton and tobacco plantations, yielding the economic leverage needed to win independence from England. As a new nation, the United States of America faced an immediate crisis when designing an unprecedented form of government: southern states depended on slave labor to produce their crops while many in the northern states felt that slavery was criminal and unacceptable. In order to establish a government, the framers of the Constitution wisely deferred decisions about slavery to a future time. Slavery for some was a way of life, for others a necessary evil, and for many in the original 13 colonies, an abhorrent and sinful practice.

Slavery was emotionally loaded even within the slave states, so it became important to create clear delineations between the different castes. Many, if not most, slave owners considered themselves Christians and in order to avoid damnation for sins against other humans, they decided that Africans were less than human and therefore among the creatures that God had instructed Adam and Eve to subdue. White masters were often sexually attracted to their slaves and pregnancies occurred. Over generations, the clear line between black and white became harder and harder to define. Many so-called blacks were much more white than black, but because they were the descendents of slaves, regardless of how much or how little African blood coursed through their veins, they were denied personhood. The Lost German Slave Girl by lawyer John Bailey, is an analysis of this twisted bit of logic. Based on a true legal case, The Lost German Slave Girl is the story of Sally Miller a slave to a cabaret owner in New Orleans, who looked as white as her master but was said to have had a black ancestor. Salome Mueller was a German child who had travelled across the Atlantic Ocean to America with her mother, father, brother, sister, and godmother in 1818. Witnesses testified that Frau and Herr Muller died en route and the brother disappeared into the Louisiana wilderness. With no money to pay for further passage, Salome and her sister were put off the riverboat and left to their fate.

About 20 years later Salome’s godmother, Eva Schuber, spied Sally Miller and “recognized” her as her missing goddaughter. Mr. Bailey builds his story around the facts of the case which are often in conflict with one another. Was Sally Miller the missing Salome Muller – a white woman wrongfully enslaved – or was she legally owned by cabaret proprietor, Louis Belmonti? Mr. Bailey has an opinion about the truth, but the point of the book is more about the rationalizations slave owners used to deny the humanity of their subjects. In order to enslave another human being, it is necessary not only to dominate him or her, but to believe that you are higher on the evolutionary chain, and therefore closer to God.

Slavery, however, was a messy business. It turns out that a surprising number of African Americans, themselves freed slaves, became slave owners. The Known World by Edward P. Jones is a fictionalized analysis of this phenomenon. According to the author, "In 1855 in Manchester County, Virginia, there were 34 free black families... and eight of those free families owned slaves." This is a staggering statistic and turns the notion of slaves being solely under the domination of white owners on its head. Because slavery caused many slave owners anguish, a number of blacks were given their freedom and they had papers to prove it. Some of these newly freed blacks had great talents and highly developed skills and were able to amass a degree of wealth. With wealth came land and land required slaves in order to make the economy of farming work. The title “The Known World” comes from a quote by Voltaire: “All the known world, excepting only savage nations, is governed by books.” It suggests not only that the keeping of slaves is an ignorant and backward practice, but also that slaves having not had the benefit of any education only knew the world within the confines of their masters’ properties. More than any other work cited here, The Known World made it clear that all men are indeed created equal whether pursuing greatness and beauty or ugliness and brutality.